English or languish - Probing the ramifications
of Hong Kong's language policy
Notes
- artificial
- The term artifcial demand is used interchangeably with
false need, even though the former has likely arisen as
a result of the latter.
- assumption - As a significant portion of English language
training is obtained by individuals in the private sector, there
is strong reason to believe that the government is unable to
provide this training more efficiently. In order to determine
whether the government is an efficient provider, it is necessary
to determine exactly what the private sector provides. If, for
example, the private sector offers English language training
very similar to that which the government sector already offers,
then the private sector is likely able to provide it better.
On the other hand, if the government and the private sector provide
complementary training (training and service that are essentially
different), then they are not in competition, and in this regard
there is no social inefficiency.
- façade
- As the Traditional Chinese Big 5 font with which this page
was produced cannot handle non-ASCII characters, the proper spelling
for the word has been provided here.
- relative
- Though one should be able to obtain a fairly accurate estimate
of the amount of money spent by government at each level of English
language competence, obtaining a rate of return that would be
comparable with other market assets is unlikely. This is because
one cannot know with any degree of precision what proportion
of total fixed costs and English language non-specific operational
costs devoted to public education should be assigned to English
language training. One can, however, assume that these fixed
and non-specific operational costs are approximately equal for
all levels of English language competence, and thus compare the
relative rates of return for each level of achievement.
- Stegemann,
R. A. 1995. English: bridge or barrier? A Socio-economic
analysis of the English language in Japan. Monograph (English).
Presented at the Ph.D Kenkyûkai Annual Conference and published
as a series of articles in the Nestling Times, a newsletter
for the Network of European Scientists and Technologists, Japan
(NEST).
- Stegemann,
R. A. 2001. English:
bridge or barrier? The political economy of the English language
in East Asia. Research manuscript (English). Presented at
the ILEC 2001 Conference, Hong Kong. Completed in 2002 and submitted
for publication.
- worth
- Unlike the general public which acquires English language competence
as both a consumption and investment good, government and business
acquire it primarily as a productive input that enhances work
performance, output, and sales. By probing government and business
demand only, the contribution of English language training to
the overall productivity of the economy can be assessed. Though
economic productivity may not be the sole criterion for teaching
English in public schools; one may question the wisdom of making
English a universal language requirement, if its direct contribution
to the economy is no longer obvious.